The Beeck Center and the Centre for Public Impact Release Joint Report to Advance Civic Technology and Open-Data Innovation in Local Government

The report details four case studies – Akron, Detroit, Macon-Bibb County, and Miami-Dade County – from The Opportunity Project for Cities

The Beeck Center for Social Impact + Innovation at Georgetown University and the Centre for Public Impact today release the findings and lessons from the third annual The Opportunity Project for Cities sprint. The 2023 program led four Knight cities and counties through a 22-week design sprint that partnered government practitioners and community organizations. The Opportunity Project for Cities is supported by Knight Foundation and the solutions are built with pro bono assistance from more than 40 Google.org product managers, engineers, data scientists, and user experience designers who provided community research, product brainstorming, technical assistance, and product development support.

Communities involved in The Opportunity Project for Cities third annual sprint included: 

  • Akron, OH who sought to address issues related to poor housing conditions and challenges related to housing rights by creating a mobile-friendly website visualizing housing complaints, evictions, and property conditions to improve residents’ decision-making. 
  • Detroit, MI who aimed to prevent over-surveying of local residents and lack of access to mobility data by developing a data-driven interactive map and report tool to help government staff and residents access data and trends on mobility.
  • Macon-Bibb County, GA who looked to address lack of access to and knowledge of business permitting processes by building an online roadmap of the permitting process that provides information to residents looking to obtain or renew business licenses.
  • Miami-Dade County, FL who planned to address severe heat issues facing commuters by creating a tool to allow residents to report on their experience at bus stops, helping with the county’s climate resiliency planning while ensuring residents are heard. 

“We are so proud to continue to partner with the Centre for Public Impact on The Opportunity Project for Cities which continues to have an outsized positive impact on people’s lives,” said Lynn Overmann, Executive Director of the Beeck Center. “We’re thrilled to share these case studies from the third annual cohort and hope that communities across the country will utilize them as an invaluable resource as they seek to better engage and serve their residents.”

The Opportunity Project for Cities program aims to surface new open data technology solutions to address public challenges and foster cultures of government transparency, accessibility, and responsiveness to strengthen trust with residents and lay the foundation for lasting community-driven innovation. The comprehensive report and toolkit released today will help inform and advance wider efforts in the field of civic innovation. Now armed with these resources, governments will be able to develop meaningful applications for local data to tackle community needs. The report shares key insights for local governments facing similar challenges. The toolkit allows anyone to replicate The Opportunity Project for Cities model. Together, these resources not only present new ways to leverage human-centered design for public interest technology but also identify new models of collaboration with community partners and technologists through civic innovation.

“In collaboration with forward-thinking organizations, government and community leaders, and tech experts, The Opportunity Project for Cities reaffirms its commitment to navigating the intricate intersection of data, technology, and community empowerment – with lessons culminated into this report” said Giselle Cordero, Program Manager for the Centre for Public Impact. “Collectively, we’re shaping an equitable and innovative future, fostering trust through dedicated collaboration with communities to authentically address concerns and work towards impactful, sustainable solutions.”

Since The Opportunity Project for Cities’ conception in 2020, the program has engaged seven local governments, 50 public servants, and over 430 residents across the U.S. A survey from the program’s second cohort showed that 100% of participants reported learning new skills as a result of participation and would recommend the program to their peers.

 This third cohort of The Opportunity Project for Cities builds upon the successes and learnings from the 2021 and 2022 sprints in communities including Detroit, MI; Long Beach, CA; Saint Paul, MN; and San José, CA, as well as Macon-Bibb County, GA, and Miami-Dade County, FL. This year, Detroit, MI; Macon-Bibb County, GA, and Miami-Dade County, FL all joined The Opportunity Project for Cities for a second sprint in the belief that further engagement with the program in renewed ways with different departments is essential to sustain cultural change.

The long term goal of The Opportunity Project for Cities is to surface new open-data technology solutions to address public challenges and foster cultures of government transparency, accessibility, and responsiveness to strengthen trust with residents and lay the foundation for lasting community-driven innovation.

###

 

About The Opportunity Project for Cities

The Opportunity Project for Cities brings together governments, community leaders, and tech volunteers to address local challenges through the power of open data and community engagement. During the program, cities and counties create a series of customized digital tools that speak to residents’ most pressing needs. The Opportunity Project for Cities builds a culture of government transparency, accessibility, and responsiveness that strengthens trust with residents and lays the foundation for lasting co-created innovation.

The Opportunity Project for Cities was inspired by the U.S. Census Bureau’s The Opportunity Project and adapted for local contexts by the Centre for Public Impact and the Beeck Center for Social Impact + Innovation at Georgetown University. The Opportunity Project for Cities is supported by the Knight Foundation and pro bono technical support from Google.org.

 

About the Beeck Center for Social Impact + Innovation at Georgetown University

The Beeck Center for Social Impact + Innovation at Georgetown University seeks to improve people’s daily lives by helping governments utilize data, design, technology, and policy to better meet the needs of their residents. An anchor of Georgetown University’s Tech and Society Initiative, the Beeck Center works alongside public, private, and non-profit organizations to identify and establish human-centered solutions that help government services work better for everyone, especially the most vulnerable and underserved populations. The Beeck Center’s work was recognized on Fast Company’s 2023 Next Big Things in Tech list. For more information, please visit beeckcenter.georgetown.edu.

 

About the Centre for Public Impact

At the Centre for Public Impact, we believe in the potential of government to bring about better outcomes for people. Yet, we have found that the systems, structures, and processes of government today are often not set up to respond to the complex challenges we face as a society. That’s why we have an emerging vision to reimagine government so that it works for everyone.

A global not-for-profit organization founded by the Boston Consulting Group, we act as a learning partner for governments, public servants, and the diverse network of changemakers who are leading the charge to reimagine government. We work with them to hold space to collectively make sense of the complex challenges we face and drive meaningful change through learning and experimentation.

 

About Knight Foundation

We are social investors who support a more effective democracy by funding free expression and journalism, arts and culture in community, research in areas of media and democracy, and in the success of American cities and towns where the Knight brothers once published newspapers. Learn more at KF.org.

 

About Google.org

Google.org’s mission is to bring the best of Google to help solve some of humanity’s biggest challenges — combining funding, in-kind product donations, and technical expertise to support underserved communities and provide opportunity for everyone.

 

Press Contacts: 

Joanna Rosholm 

Original Strategies 

beeckcenter@originalstrategies.com  

 

Elysa Neumann

Communications Specialist

Centre for Public Impact

elysa@centreforpublicimpact.org

‪202-630-3383

Postcards from the Community: Digital Benefits Network Team Visits Michigan

Since 2022, the Digital Benefits Network has been steadily growing the community of practitioners working to expand equitable access to public benefits through the implementation of innovative and proven approaches. In 2023, we hosted the inaugural BenCon and the ever-growing Digital Benefits Hub was used by over 13,000 practitioners. DBN is starting 2024 with momentum and added two new staff to the team in January. This team hit the ground running and headed to Michigan to visit network partners−Civilla, Michigan Unemployment Insurance AgencyUniversity of Michigan’s Poverty Solutions Lab, and Taubman Urban Technology−March 12-13, 2024.

Let team DBN−Ariel Kennan (Senior Director), Jennifer Phillips (Program Lead Network Collaboration), Elizabeth Bynum Sorrell (Project Researcher), Maya Salemeh (Program + Data Manager), and Tina Amper (Community Advisor, Rules As Code Community of Practice)−take you on a virtual tour and share what we learned!

Read more on the Digital Benefits Hub

Beeck Center Releases Impact Report Highlighting a Year of Sustained Growth and Innovative Partnerships

The Beeck Center for Social Impact + Innovation at Georgetown University is thrilled to release our 2023 Impact Report, a reflection on our work, accomplishments, and impact last year. In the report, we highlight the successes of our project teams, the contributions of our many new staff members and student analysts, our growing engagement with students across Georgetown University, and our crucial network of partners and funders. 

In 2023, we hosted 30 events with a total of more than 4,000 attendees, engaged with more than 3,000 practitioners in our networks, received $7 million in new funding commitments, published 18 reports, and welcomed nine new staff members. In March, Lynn Overmann joined the Beeck Center as our new executive director, and her transformative leadership continues to inspire our teams and drive our impact.

“As we reflect on a year of high-impact work and targeted growth at the Beeck Center, I am honored to lead a team dedicated to facilitating equitable systems change, fostering innovation, and inspiring the next generation of social impact leaders,” Overmann said. 

This year, the Beeck Center ran six different projects all designed to solve pressing societal challenges, ranging from delivering public benefits, to leveraging digital transformation best practices, to increasing government capacity to deliver on policy and administration priorities. From hosting public events to publishing reports to gathering changemakers in common spaces, all six projects made great strides in creating tangible impact on the communities and goals they target. 

As we enter 2024, which marks the 10th anniversary of our founding, we look forward to the opportunity to acknowledge our achievements, yet we are also humbled by the work still to be done. We know that the next 10 years will hold new challenges to tackle and future accomplishments to celebrate, so we encourage you to follow along with our teams’ incredible work as we continue to target transformation at scale. 

Read the full 2023 Impact Report.

Data Labs Now Accepting Project Proposals for Its Third Cohort

The award winning program will offer select states hands-on support for data projects tackling the areas of safety net benefits, workforce transitions, and student outcomes

Recently recognized on Fast Company’s Next Big Things in Tech list, Data Labs—a collaboration between the Beeck Center for Social Impact + Innovation and the National Governors Association (NGA)—is accepting proposals for the 2024 cohort. To be selected in April, the cohort will be composed of state data and policy leaders from across the country that will embark on an eight-month program designed to offer hands-on support in the execution of a thoughtfully-designed data project intended to improve safety net benefits, workforce transitions, and student outcomes.

Data Labs uses a human-centered design approach to help states launch data-sharing projects that improve government services and the lives of residents. This year’s program builds upon the program’s legacy of helping states redefine the role of data in decision making to drive immediate and long-term improvements in people’s lives. Previous cohorts have focused on key issue areas including student outcomes, housing and houselessness, small business support, workforce support, and safety net benefits. 

 “We are thrilled to be continuing our Data Labs program in partnership with NGA,” said Lynn Overmann, Executive Director of the Beeck Center. “This program serves as a powerful catalyst for change in how state governments use data to address pressing societal challenges, and we are excited to collaborate with this next cohort of innovative states to help build a future that is more equitable, inclusive, and prosperous for all.”

Data Labs is accepting project proposals from states that are hoping to focus on one of three key issue areas:

  • Safety Net Benefits: Improving access to and administration of programs such as Medicaid, SNAP, WIC, EITC, CTC, and UI. 
  • Workforce Transitions: Understanding pathways to employment and improving access to career opportunities.
  • Student Outcomes: Using longitudinal data to improve student progress and outcomes, from preschool to post-secondary school.

State participants will gain invaluable insights from national experts, practitioners, and peers. The program pairs a human-centered design curriculum with individualized support to give state teams a framework to think through data challenges and solutions, as well as customized guidance that meets them where they are and helps advance their goals to champion data innovation in government.

“NGA is pleased to continue to partner with the Beeck Center on its innovative Data Labs program,” said Tim Blute, director of NGA’s Center for Best Practices. “The use and sharing of data is key to driving progress on Governors’ top priorities, and we look forward to working with state leaders as they harness data to make government programs more effective.”

Many individuals and families across the country have benefited from their state’s participation in the Data Labs program. In Colorado, a historic investment of $250M was committed for data infrastructure and analysis to address homelessness, and in Oregon, a first-of-its-kind multi-agency analysis provided a more granular, regional-level understanding of the state’s nursing shortage in order to develop stronger solutions for improving educational pathways to the healthcare industry. Data Labs is committed to being a resource for all states, and published the Data Labs Playbook to provide a practical guide for public servants who want to launch a data-sharing project, offering best practices, key questions, and tactical tools to advance any data project action plan, whether the project is new or existing.

Data Labs will be accepting project proposals through March 29. Selected proposals will be notified by April 5, and the program will run from April to November 2024. Please visit http://tinyurl.com/data-labs to learn more and submit a proposal. Have questions or need further information? Email us at datalabs@georgetown.edu.

Navigating the unknown: Colorado’s data-driven approach to tackling Long COVID challenges

How Data Labs kickstarted the state’s efforts to prioritize data infrastructure in the face of crisis

For Katherine Hochevar, life looked vastly different at the end of COVID-19 pandemic than it had at the beginning. In the span of two years, she found out she was pregnant, gave birth to her son, and changed her career from K-12 education to join the data management team at the State of Colorado’s Office of Information Technology, all amidst an unprecedented global health crisis. 

Then, a “new normal” began to emerge as the world set out on shaky legs to regain its bearings and begin its self-proclaimed recovery. Hochevar, and countless others, came back to offices left vacant for more than a year.

“Except, not everyone came back,” she said. “There was some loss of life, but there were also people who just couldn’t come back–people you no longer saw in meetings or spoke to at lunch. That was one of the first times it became very close to home.”

In early 2021, the concept of Long COVID was not widely recognized, or at least a name had not yet been put to it. Today, the term represents a condition with many subsets and more than 200 potential symptoms that can affect nearly every part of the body—from extreme fatigue and brain fog to tachycardia, joint pain, headaches and everything in between. While much is still unknown about Long COVID, and the condition itself is largely self-reported, research has found that 14 percent of Americans say they have suffered from it at some point. Additionally, due to the unpredictable and often debilitating nature of the condition, more than half of these individuals become part-time employees or are out of work entirely after infection.

Photo by Ani Kolleshi on Unsplash

Colorado is one of the only states in the nation to tackle the issue of Long COVID head-on. In Colorado’s Next Chapter: Our Roadmap to Moving Forward, released in February 2022, the Polis-Primavera administration had the foresight to call for investment and research into the disease. Colorado House Bill 22-1401 authorized the Office of Saving People Money on Health Care to undertake this work. 

Estimates in the state show that there may be as many as 651,000 individuals who developed Long COVID by December 2022. Based on the current labor force participation rate in the state, experts say between 173,000 and 304,000 working-age (18 to 65) Coloradans are experiencing Long COVID and between 140,000 and 250,000 people with Long COVID have been participating in the workforce, with more than a quarter of them likely experiencing significant activity limitations due to their illness.

“But estimates cannot paint a full picture, and they cannot get Coloradans the help they need to be able to fully reclaim their lives, participate in their communities, and contribute to the economy,” Hochevar said.

“The true extent of the problem just isn’t known,” she said. “And how can we monitor what we don’t know? How will we know if the problem is growing, shrinking, staying the same? How much energy should we put toward mitigating some of the impacts of Long COVID? We need better information.”

Lt. Governor Dianne Primavera (center) and Dr. Mirwais Baheej (right), along with staff from the Office of Saving People Money on Health Care staff, visited the University of Colorado Anschutz Long Covid Multidisciplinary Clinic (Photo courtesy of the Office of Lt. Governor Dianne Primavera).

Throughout their pandemic response, Colorado prioritized data-driven decisionmaking data transparency. That’s why in March 2023, Hochevar and a cross-functional state team led by the Office of Saving People Money on Health Care and Colorado’s senior policy advisor on Long COVID, Dr. Mirwais Baheej, joined Data Labs—an eight-month program designed by the Beeck Center for Social Impact + Innovation and the National Governors Association to offer hands-on support in the execution of thoughtfully-designed data projects intended to improve workforce transitions, safety net benefits, and student outcomes. Colorado was one of six states—including Arizona, Connecticut, West Virginia, Minnesota, and Nevada—to join the second cohort of the program, which pairs a human-centered design curriculum with individualized support to give state teams a framework to think through data challenges and solutions, as well as customized guidance that meets them where they are at. 

The Colorado team entered Data Labs with the goal of building a framework to plan for Long COVID’s impact on the state. To understand the disease’s effect on workforce transitions, the team aimed to identify its data needs, develop a comprehensive data system to inform policy, and work to improve access to career opportunities for those impacted by Long COVID.

“People with Long COVID face a period of uncertainty while they wait for confirmation from their health care provider on a diagnosis. There isn’t a simple test you can take,” said Dr. Baheej. “And because so many employers’ organizational policies are diagnosis-led when it comes to benefits and leave, while people wait for their diagnosis they can’t return to work, they can’t manage their time, they can’t plan for the future.”

Dr. Baheej knows firsthand the complexities of navigating a Long COVID diagnosis, and the role that diagnosis can play in a person’s life. In early 2022, his brother-in-law, having had COVID a few months prior, began experiencing a host of health problems, which his doctors attributed to congestive heart failure. For a construction worker who owned his own business, the news was devastating. 

It was a cardiologist who eventually suggested that the original diagnosis may be incorrect, and introduced both Dr. Baheej and his brother-in-law to the concept of Long COVID. 

“Even as a medical doctor, myself, Long COVID was not something I had heard of or really understood yet; we all initially thought Long COVID had to do with your mental health, and not your physical health,” Dr. Baheej said.

A characteristic of Long COVID that differentiates it from many other serious, long term illnesses—and which Dr. Baheej saw in the case of his brother-in-law—is that recovery is possible. With the right support and accommodations from employers, people can also continue working and, in turn, keep their benefits.

But, in order to provide that support, employers need guidance and policies to adhere to from the State or the federal government, but the State cannot provide direction without an understanding of the scope of the problem. As the Data Labs team dug in, they quickly realized what was needed was a strategic approach to large scale data-sharing efforts at the state level.

“In a lot of ways, this project has been like a needs analysis of finding where our gaps are. Where are the siloes? Where do we need to be doing something different entirely?” Hochevar said. “We’re going to have to establish some better pathways when we do need to share data and I don’t know that I would have even been involved in this process or even aware of the need for this work had it not been for Data Labs.”

Beyond the technical framework the team is building to improve the State’s data-sharing capacity, the team also realized the need to build out a framework for engaging with the less concrete aspects of the project: the people. After hitting roadblocks in their attempts to bring various agencies together, the team, with the support of Data Labs Program Manager Vinith Annam, saw that the people were also siloed.

“We needed to make people see themselves and their agencies in this process. So why call it a project? It’s so much more than that,” Dr. Baheej said. “It is something that is affecting all of our systems—health, workforce, education, the socio-economic fabric of society and the wellbeing of Coloradans. So we needed to shift from a project mindset to a collaborative one. If we get there, then we’ll be addressing things in a whole-of-government and a whole-of-society way.”

To that end, the Colorado team used their time in Data Labs to make significant headway in defining a data surveillance strategy and estimating the burden of Long COVID on the workforce to inform policy. The team has also established communication processes with the state agencies and other stakeholders to better understand the needs and challenges inherent in sharing data, convened leaders of existing data collaboratives to share best practices, and enhanced their existing short term data sharing mechanisms.

Equally as important, though, is the groundwork the team has laid for how the State responds to the next crisis. 

“What if it’s another pandemic, or climate change?” Hochevar said. “Data Labs has taught us how to position people to come to the table to talk about a novel problem, how to get the right technology to support the investigation of this problem, and how to bring people together at the right time. Those skills are invaluable no matter the crisis.”


Interested in joining the next cohort of Data Labs? We are now accepting proposals for our third cohort. Click here to learn more and apply, or contact datalabs@georgetown.edu.

Beeck Center Announces Government AI Hire, Use, Buy (HUB) Roundtable Series

Georgetown University’s Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET) and the Beeck Center for Social Impact and Innovation, together with the Georgetown Law Institute for Technology Law and Policy (Tech Institute), are leading a series of invite-only roundtables examining the government’s use of artificial intelligence (AI).

The rise of AI has profoundly impacted every sector, extending its influence across government, the private sector, and academia. At a pivotal moment in late 2023, President Biden signed the groundbreaking Executive Order on the Safe, Secure, and Trustworthy Development and Use of Artificial Intelligence. A number of provisions in the EO highlighted the growing role that AI will play in government operations.

The series will bring together leading voices to grapple with the legal liability questions that AI poses, examine AI’s potential to transform government services, and consider how the government can better attract and use AI talent. The initiative is funded by a generous grant from the Rockefeller Foundation.

The three centers, all members of Georgetown University’s Tech & Society Initiative, will lead a series of roundtables in 2024 with officials across government, civil society, academia, and the private sector to examine the U.S. government’s role as a

  • user of AI systems;
  • employer of AI talent; and
  • buyer of AI systems.

After each roundtable, high-level takeaways will be made public. The series will conclude with a final roundtable to synthesize conclusions from earlier events and provide final, actionable policy recommendations for the community. Results of this concluding roundtable will feature in a final public webinar.

We invite anyone with additional questions to reach out to Danny Hague (danny.hague@georgetown.edu) for more details.

Hiring Spotlight: Maryland Family and Medical Leave Insurance

The Digital Service Network (DSN) recently sat down with the Maryland Family and Medical Leave Insurance (FAMLI) team to learn more about an exciting role they’re hiring for.

About the team

Maryland’s Family and Medical Leave Insurance​​ (FAMLI) system ensures that all workers in Maryland have paid time off for medical and family reasons. As a digitally native government service, the FAMLI team strives to make their program inclusive, simple, and easy to use. They’re engaging the people who depend on them—workers, employers, caregivers, and insurers—to learn what they need, and responding to those needs swiftly, respectfully, and meaningfully.

FAMLI is a $2 billion social insurance system, delivered as a digitally-native public-facing service. The Digital Services Team is central to bringing a modern, product-oriented approach to creating, launching, and continuously improving the digital platform powering family and medical leave in Maryland. The team is responsible for providing intuitive and user-oriented experiences to workers who need to take paid leave, to employers who need to interact with our office, and to the government employees processing claims and engaging with the public.

As a part of the Digital Services team you will be on the front line of making paid leave for Marylanders possible. Through human-centered approaches to product development the team aims to create pathways for all Maryland employees and employers to interact with their program and receive this critical benefit in times of need.

This is a greenfield opportunity to be a part of building the tools and organization that will be delivering critical benefits to millions of Marylanders.

The team is hiring

The FAMLI Division is currently hiring a head of user experience and service design. See the full job description. This position reports to the director of digital services for FAMLI and collaborates with teams across the division, including community engagement, policy, and communications. This is a hybrid position, based in the Maryland Department of Labor in Baltimore, MD. 

Diving Deeper

What are you looking for in a candidate? 

This role is a critical part of the FAMLI Digital Services leadership team. As the head of user experience and service design we’re looking for someone who can bring multiple years of experience in user research, service design, and/or project management to the team. This role will oversee and help prioritize multiple concurrent threads of user research as well as supervise up to three product owners in their management of the most crucial software-development workstreams for FAMLI.  This is a first-line supervisory position and a second-line managerial position.

The head of user experience and service design position is a career-defining opportunity for someone passionate about using a human-centered approach to deliver essential benefits to our users. The head of user experience and service design will have the opportunity to help shape the foundation for all of FAMLI’s digital products. The ideal candidate will have experience with human-centered design, building and executing a digital product vision, and collaborating and communicating effectively with technical and non-technical stakeholders.

How do these roles contribute to the organization’s broader mission? 

This role is a critical part of the FAMLI Digital Services leadership team and is responsible for holding the organization accountable to our goal of building software that serves our end users and staff with respect and compassion. This role sets the standards for product ownership and user research across the program and also maintains the shared understanding of how our users interact across our services.

What does the hiring process look like? What should a candidate expect? 

Candidates must submit their applications by the posted deadline. Phone interviews will start about a week after the application period closes. Selected candidates will participate in two interviews with different members of the FAMLI team. 

Any advice for a candidate applying? 

We recognize that everyone brings skills and experiences to the table and that not everyone “checks all the boxes.” Apply anyway! Tell us why you’re the right fit for the job. Don’t forget to attach your resume and cover letter to your application. 

We’re interested in talking to candidates from diverse professional backgrounds who are passionate about building a human-centered product that will touch the lives of all Marylanders.

Why should a candidate consider applying to any of these roles? 

Joining the FAMLI team is a rare opportunity to shape a new program that will lend financial stability and job security to millions. By joining the FAMLI Digital Services Team, you’ll be at the forefront of this innovative approach and creating lasting impact.

Resources

Reforming the form: a step toward more effective government

By Anaya Mehta, Digital Benefits Network Student Analyst

Forms are a key part of what makes government work: they facilitate a conversation between officials and the public, are crucial for public service delivery, and can enable the government to operate more effectively.

Co-hosted by Code for America (CfA) and the Digital Service Network (DSN) at the Beeck Center for Social Impact + Innovation on November 8, 2023, FormFest 2023 brought together representatives from government agencies across the United Kingdom, Canada, France, New Zealand, and the United States for a half-day event to showcase how governments and organizations are using and improving forms to make government more accessible. The event featured U.S. government agencies from the city, county, state, and federal levels, as well as civic tech organizations, sharing new initiatives for improving digital forms.

After an initial welcome from Marlena Medford, director of communications at CfA and Kirsten Wyatt, Beeck Center fellow and director of the DSN, attendees heard from Mina Hsiang, administrator of the U.S. Digital Service. 

Hsiang emphasized that when forms meet citizens where they are and leverage information an agency already has, they have the potential to increase efficiency and access to government services. She underscored the importance of removing potentially redundant questions and improving user interfaces to make forms more interactive and user-friendly. 

During the multi-hour event, attendees heard from a range of presenters during deep dives and demo sessions, and had opportunities to network with their fellow attendees.

 

Breakout Sessions

Deep Dives

Measuring a Form’s administrative burden…in real time

During the session, Measuring a form’s administrative burden…in real time, Quinten Steenhuis and Bryce Willey from the Suffolk University Law School Legal Innovation Technology Lab introduced attendees to the automated tool RateMyPDF. The RateMyPDF tool helps courts improve the readability and usability of court forms by running an automated analysis of a form and identifying opportunities to improve. 

Improvements include reducing the time required to complete a form and ensuring that a form is in line with the reading and comprehension level of users. The tool can help courts identify forms that they might prioritize for improvements based on the tool’s score. While the tool was designed for court documents, RateMyPDF can also parse other kinds of government forms, making it a valuable tool for improving forms vital to public service delivery.

 

When we can’t do digital: Flexibility in paper forms

In the session, When we can’t do digital: Flexibility in paper forms, Debra Scott from the DC Housing Authority discussed how the agency collaborated with The Lab @ DC to improve the housing voucher application process. The DC Housing Authority decided to implement a paper-based form revision rather than digitizing the form. Their reasoning was that digitizing forms is time consuming, some users may prefer paper forms and would be better supported in-person by case managers, and digitization could be complex since the housing voucher application process involves multiple agencies. 

Nellie Moore and Ryan Flynn from the Lab @ DC explained how they used a “modular logic approach” by reducing the number of forms and questions that users need to fill out and incorporating clearer instructions and section labels for users to improve user experience and reduce delays in processing applications. The transformed paper form is significantly shorter and specific to the type of voucher the user is applying for, employs skip logic to improve wayfinding, and eliminates redundant questions.

 

Building accessible forms at Code for America

Margaret Thorpe, Devon Hirth, Karen Chou, Alex Gonzalez, and Cypress Borg, presenters from Code for America, shared insights on developing accessible Java Spring-based application forms. Their session, Building accessible forms at Code for America, highlighted how engineers strive to create user-friendly forms, aiding agencies in efficient form-creation processes. The tool aims to make forms perceivable, understandable, operable, and robust using accessible rich internet applications (ARIA properties) and rigorous testing through tools like Assistiv Labs and WAVE browser extensions that flag accessibility issues on forms. Features include language selectors, meaningful labels to guide text inputs, and live templates which are default codes for common buttons, inputs or entire screens that engineers can create using just a couple lines of code.

 

No coding needed: Empowering teams to build digital forms

In the session, No coding needed: Empowering teams to build digital forms, Tim Arney, Sam Sadasivan and Carolyn Connors from the Canada Digital Service discussed the creation of GC forms, a self-service form builder tool to help Canadian agencies publish application forms quickly and easily without coding. 

The team shared how the process of rolling out GC Forms focused on early and continuous delivery of valuable software and a simplistic design to create a Minimum Valuable Product (MVP) through an iterative process. The GC Forms MVP was improved based on feedback from agencies through demo and support requests, and research sessions to better meet the needs of agencies.  

 

Lessons learned from GOV.UK Forms private beta launch

During the session, Lessons learned from GOV.UK forms private beta launch, Betty Mwema, Hazal Arpalikli, Oliver Quinlan, and Iain Boyd from the GOV.UK Forms team discussed the feedback they have received on a new form building tool they are developing to help civil servants create more accessible forms for the services their department delivers. They received feedback from 11 select government agency partners in the “private beta” phase of their project, and their plan to improve their tool in their “early access” phase based on the feedback they received. 

While this tool served as a good template for application forms across agencies, the GOV.UK team understood that some agency problems were better solved using agency-specific tools. Currently, the team is working on adding more features to improve the functionality and efficiency of the form-building tool, including allowing for more complex routing as well as options to upload documents and preview the form as it’s being made.

 

Aotearoa/New Zealand’s form builders find the sweet spot

Shelley Campbell from New Zealand’s Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment discussed the execution of Formbuilder.govt by Business Connect, a government service which aims to make it easier for businesses to contract with the government, in the session, Aotearoa/New Zealand’s form builders find the sweet spot. Business Connect’s Formbuilder.govt platform is an open-source, form-building software designed by the government to facilitate the application process for businesses contracting with specific government agencies. The platform aims to improve both the user experience for businesses and the overall efficiency of government agencies involved in contracting processes by prototyping user-friendly and accessible AA 2.1 compliant forms in a couple of hours, saving time and money for agencies. 

 

Designing inclusive forms with the U.S. Web Design System (USWDS)

In another session, Designing inclusive forms with the U.S. Web Design System (USWDS), Anne Petersen from USWDS and Austin Hernandez from 18F discussed 17 inclusive design patterns from the US Web Design System. These design patterns are based on the premise of creating an inclusive user experience, increasing transparency and consent, and protecting users by only collecting relevant data. The USWDS is a plain-language resource for practical usability advice drawn from user-experience research, which includes pattern recommendations and important terminology definitions to help both agencies and users. 

Their pattern recommendations focus on improving questions that agencies frequently ask, including name, gender identity, and race questions. These recommendations guide agencies to incorporate appropriate user input options and provide users with clear instructions and sample response examples.

 

From paper trails to digital pathways: France’s form journey

During the session, From paper trails to digital pathways: France’s form journey, Paul Chavard from beta.gouv.fr discusses the features, uses, and challenges of Démarches simplifiées (Simplified Procedures in English),an open-source, self-service, form-building tool that provides a template for local administrations in France to build and publish forms quickly. 

Chavard noted that while this tool increases efficiency, it can be challenging to develop forms because administrations may have different technical capabilities and users face different digital access issues. Nonetheless, the tool has helped administrations publish forms quickly with its various features, including options for file attachments and conditional fields. Démarches simplifiées has already helped agencies develop forms in emergency situations in just days or weeks. 

 

Demos

Demo: Unemployment insurance forms and rules as code

The demo session Unemployment Insurance forms and rules as code highlighted two different projects: New Jersey’s efforts to improve their Unemployment Insurance forms and the work by the Digital Benefits Network (DBN) to explore standardized rules as code to improve government operations and service delivery. 

In the demo, team members from the New Jersey Office of Innovation walked through New Jersey’s work to make the state’s Unemployment Insurance claims process more accessible. The team emphasized how the state intentionally incorporated user feedback, built trust within the team and with partners, and took a “tool agnostic” approach in order to better serve residents. 

Ariel Kennan and Tina Amper of the DBN also presented on the idea of rules as code,exploring how the creation of standardized, open source, and computer-consumable eligibility rules as code could improve transparency and efficiency across public benefits programs. As Amper and Kennan noted, standardized rules as code can help agencies avoid duplicative work and enable cross-program and policy comparisons.  

 

Demo: Forms in Boston, MA and Seattle, WA

In another demo session, Demos: Forms in Boston, MA and Seattle, WA, representatives from the City of Boston discussed the creation of gender-inclusive forms while the City of Seattle provided a demonstration of Civiform, an open-source, no code, form building and integration tool that creates “forms on the fly.” 

Paul Chong, Candace Nguyen, and Stephanie Cariello from the City of Boston demonstrated their human-centered approach to building gender-inclusive marriage license forms.. The team’s demo offered recommendations to make forms and certificates more gender neutral, and shared a gender data collection playbook to help city-wide agencies appropriately collect gender data. 

From the Seattle team, Elise Kalstad and Miguel Jimenez discussed Civiform’s features that improve staff and resident experiences in applying for and receiving public assistance. The tool flags eligibility conditions that users need to meet for programs, enables status messages for staff to give updates to residents, recommends programs for users to apply for based on their previous applications, and includes options to auto-fill answers to universal questions across benefits program application forms.

 

Demos: Forms in Sonoma County, CA and Syracuse, NY

In the demo session, Demos: Forms in Sonoma County, CA and Syracuse, NY, the Sonoma County team shared Sonoma County’s journey to digitization, and the City of Syracuse team discussed their efforts to make procurement and city contracts more accessible and fair for diverse local vendors competing with larger firms. 

Cieara McKetcnie-Stanley, Gregory Williams, and Carolyn Staats from the Sonoma County team walked attendees through the creation of their digitization strategy and implementation plan, which leveraged tools like SimplyGov,Adobe Sign, and DC Pro, partnerships with subject matter experts in the agencies to design and educate staff about digitization, and analytics to track and manage projects. 

From  Syracuse, Rebecca Lumpkin and Jordanna Coutinho joined Mia Capone from the Harvard Kennedy School Government Performance Lab to discuss the City’s efforts to transform the Minority or Women-owned Businesses (MWBE) vendor certification process. The team updated application resources and websites, created a renewal and expansion application process to address active vendor drop off and keep vendor profiles up to date, and established a digital directory for complete vendor profiles.

 

Humanizing the form experience

After the day’s breakout session presentations, FormFest concluded with a closing panel featuring Caroline Jarrett, the forms and surveys specialist at Effortmark Ltd; Dana Chisnell, the executive director for Customer Experience of the Department of Homeland Security; and Stephanie Wade, the founder and CEO of Ascendant. 

The panelists emphasized that form-makers should be intentional about the questions they ask users on forms and avoid asking users to input more data than is necessary. Although fixing and revising forms can be a challenging undertaking, the panelists underscored that improving forms can have a transformative impact by reducing administrative costs and saving money, and most importantly, making life better for the public. 


All videos from FormFest 2023 are now available on the DSN’s YouTube channel. Sign up today to stay connected with the DSN, and check out the DSN resource library at https://DigitalServiceNetwork.org



Promising Practices in State Unemployment Insurance Digital Service Delivery

By Maxim Zeidman, Digital Benefits Network Student Analyst

In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) provided funding to modernize unemployment insurance (UI) by appropriating $2 billion to the Department of Labor (DOL); however, $1 billion was later rescinded under the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023. The DOL inaugurated the Office of ​​Unemployment Insurance Modernization (OUIM) to guide and manage ARPA investments against three main goals: expand equitable access, improve timeliness, and strengthen program integrity. OUIM has supported states in their modernization journeys through grants, technical assistance, services, products, and resources. 

States have shown resilience in facing ongoing challenges and have found creative ways to apply the ARPA grants, such as developing layered modular systems, ensuring adaptive technology, improving data security, and balancing accessibility and fraud prevention. However, due to the cyclical nature of UI funding and the uncertainty of future administrative funding streams, states must exercise caution with budgetary allocations and investment decisions. It will be important for Congress, DOL, and states to continue to invest in improving UI systems to meet the needs of residents ahead of future economic downturns. 

Throughout Spring 2023, the Beeck Center’s Digital Benefits Network (DBN) interviewed state leaders from Illinois, New Jersey, Michigan, and Oregon, as well as representatives from the National Association of State Workforce Agencies (NASWA), about their experiences delivering UI—ranging from customer experience, language access, digital delivery, and data and analytics. The DBN’s outreach has shed light on promising practices emerging from states’ efforts to modernize UI systems—approaches that have potential to improve efficiency, security, and lead to more equitable outcomes. We detail these below to inspire practices for other states to replicate.

Language Access 

Developing multiple language frameworks simultaneously 

Several of the states we consulted prioritized improving the clarity, inclusiveness, and effectiveness of external communications. When claimants understand and navigate UI systems with ease, they are more likely to complete the process and receive the benefits they need. The Oregon Employment Department, in efforts to expand language access, developed different language frameworks simultaneously, rather than translating directly from an English source. This parallel development strategy seeks to optimize equity by tailoring user interfaces to the needs of specific non-English-language communities. To this end, Oregon has offered their UI application in Spanish and created multilingual educational videos. Oregon emphasized that partnering with native non-English-speaking communities and organizations has enabled this process.

Partnering to meet community need 

The states we interviewed recognize the importance of accurate and understandable translations in increasing the accessibility of UI, and have attempted various strategies that prioritize different components of the service delivery process. The New Jersey Department of Labor & Workforce Development is developing a plain language, mobile-friendly application, which they have released using a phased approach — releasing first to 25 users in October 2023, then scaling up to 10% of users in November 2023, 50% by December 2023, and 100% of users by January 2024. They used each of these phases to identify where claimants were getting stuck or answering questions incorrectly in a way that required agent intervention, and made those improvements before the next phase of release. In collaboration with United States Digital Response (USDR), New Jersey piloted a new methodology that utilized subject matter experts on their team and in their community to ensure effective Spanish translation for the new intake application. They began by translating sections of their initial intake application into Spanish and soliciting feedback from front-line call center staff who speak to claimants about their challenges daily in Spanish. They then connected with community partners who work with Spanish speaking communities to review and share additional ideas for improvement, sometimes resulting in the phrase being presented in multiple ways and/or with the English phrase in parenthesis.

Customer Experience 

Developing aids to support claimants

Michigan’s Unemployment Insurance Agency (UIA) is working to translate correspondence to jobless workers and develop online resources, such as informational videos, to address the needs of those who do not speak English as their primary language or have visual disabilities. In August 2023, UIA released a new UIA Claimant Roadmap, which consolidates and clarifies filing information into step-by-step guidance. UIA partnered with nonprofit design studio Civilla to iteratively design the guide and seek feedback from the public and agency staff. UIA has started hosting virtual, no-cost “First-time Filer Coaching Sessions” where claimants can receive guidance from trained UIA instructors on how to apply for benefits and understand what they need to do to maintain those benefits.

Improving email communication

New Jersey has updated over 50 emails with clear, trustworthy language that encourages claimants to act with urgency without threatening them or emphasizing negative consequences. By using an action-forward approach, New Jersey has been able to reduce the time for claimants to submit information by 35%. As part of these efforts, New Jersey created a re-usable email toolkit that contains a collection of styles, components, and building blocks to replicate in other states. 

Data & Analytics

Partnering to hone approach and analysis 

Data collection and analysis offers the opportunity to identify pain points during the UI application and after someone receives benefits. Administrators can identify and alter segments of the process where claimants face difficulties, including technical issues that could inhibit successful filings. The Illinois Department of Employment Security leveraged the expertise and capacity of external associates and surveyed customers using a survey at the end of the application to identify pain points and learn more about their experiences. Administrators partnered with DOL and their Tiger Team to refine the survey questions and expeditiously analyze data using scripts written in the programming language Python. Illinois has also partnered with masters students at the University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy to explore survey data and customer experience as a capstone project, providing respective recommendations. The state is working to implement an additional pop-up survey throughout the application to understand abandonment and other pain points in user experience. 

Building analytics into migration 

New Jersey is building analytics into their digital services as they migrate from an outdated legacy system. For example, they are creating dashboards using Google Analytics data to understand error rates and the usage of key functions like scheduling an appointment, requesting overpayment waivers, and managing accounts. Additionally, New Jersey issues claimant surveys after the initial claim completion and identity verification, prompting users to comment on challenges or questions they faced, if the user understood they needed to do weekly certification, and completing identity verification. This has created a feedback loop that helps them continue to make improvements incrementally, release them quickly to residents, and gather feedback on the next improvements to prioritize

Digital Transformation

Understanding the claimant experience 

Funded by a DOL equity grant, Illinois is developing three robust data sets that capture claimant information concerning likelihood to file, payment timeliness, and likelihood to exhaust benefits. Administrators plan to use these research findings to inform front-end development, optimizing the accessibility and delivery of UI. The state is also working with private contractors to revamp their online claimant portal user interface to enable mobile access and develop new features, including text message, correspondence, and status tracking capabilities. Illinois state leaders affirmed that self-serve options and users’ ability to access their own information are paramount for equity—they are also prioritizing increasing customers’ ability to access staff, and working on plain language and translation efforts.

Building consensus 

As part of their digital system evolution, Oregon has begun requiring internal communication and consensus between program experts, the UI modernization teams (both internal and external vendor teams), internal communications experts, and their Equity and Inclusion Office on all initiatives. Requiring these teams to communicate and come to consensus has been time consuming but effective in developing a unified UI strategy and changing the agency’s approach so its communications are more understandable to the diverse communities it serves

Going out to the community 

Michigan has partnered with affinity groups and community centers through its Community Connect Program to understand how to best improve and offer service delivery by going on-site to communities that would be most impacted by improvements. The program also works with employers who are anticipating laying off staff. The state also established a UIA Modernization Workgroup made up of business, labor, and jobless advocates who help to guide modernization reforms while prioritizing equity, customer service, and combating fraud.

What’s Next

Since the Beeck Center conducted these interviews, the DOL has released and awarded additional UI grants to states. In July 2023, the DOL announced a strategic approach to distributing the remaining UI modernization funds in Letter No. 11-23. The letter announced additional grant opportunities for Integrity, Information Technology (IT) Modernization, and Tiger Teams. On September 22, 2023, the DOL issued $204 million in UI grants to 18 states and the U.S. Virgin Islands. These grants seek to build upon evidence-based promising practices and support strategies such as modular software development and API-first development approaches.

The DOL has also released a new report celebrating the successes and highlighting the insights from ARPA investment in UI modernization. ARPA investments have not only brought about immediate improvements in states, but have also set in motion the development of sustainable and adaptive UI systems. The collaboration between states and the DOL, guided by a comprehensive strategy, ensures that lessons learned and successes achieved are not isolated instances but catalysts for a more robust and equitable UI landscape across the United States.

Acknowledgements 

Thank you to UI state leaders, including Julia Dale, Michigan Unemployment Insurance Agency; Jennifer Phillips, Illinois Department of Employment Security; Gillian Morejon Gutierrez, New Jersey Department of Labor & Workforce Development; and David Gerstenfeld, Oregon Employment Department. Thank you to NASWA leaders Brett Flachsbarth, Benjamin Peirce, and Lou Ansaldi. 

Georgetown students embedded in our teams are central to how we work at the Beeck Center. We are grateful to McCourt School of Public Policy Master of Public Policy candidate Oriel Gomez for designing and conducting the interviews with state UI leaders in the Spring 2023 semester, followed by Georgetown Bachelor of Science in Computer Science and Political Economy candidate Maxim Zeidman for writing this summary of promising practices in the Fall 2023 semester. This work has been overseen by Ariel Kennan, Fellow and Research Faculty for the Digital Benefits Network.

Lessons from Abroad: Beeck works internationally to encourage further digital innovation within the U.S.

From Kazakhstan to the UK, U.S. governments at all levels can—and should—look to other countries around the globe for lessons on advancing digitization and access to public services. The Beeck Center for Social Impact + Innovation has recently been engaging internationally to better understand diverse approaches to technological innovation for public service, with the eventual goal of helping replicate some of these at home. 

Through this extensive global engagement, the Beeck Center has celebrated the opportunity to share experiences and initiatives with others across the world, yet it has also shone a light on where the U.S. can improve its own digital innovation efforts.

 

Shaping new ideas through international collaboration 

In October, Beeck Center’s Executive Director Lynn Overmann and Fellow Dominic Campbell spoke on the opening panel at the Solace Summit, a three-day conference in Birmingham, England, that hosted 400 senior leaders from local governments in the UK, as well as visitors from around the world. Overmann and Campbell joined Marc Stears—director of University College London’s Policy Lab—to reflect on government transformation in both the U.S. and UK since 2010. The panel shared thoughts on what countries can learn from this journey when imagining the inevitable acceleration of government change in the coming decade.

Above all, the panel pointed to the role of strategic leadership in navigating through transitions in government administration, particularly the shifting nature of federal relations with state and local governments. Beyond DC and Westminster, panelists also highlighted a shift in the way other governments are partnering with communities and focusing on putting citizens at the heart of public services—a trend that is set to continue and be supercharged as institutions take one redesign and modernization efforts.

Overmann also met with several leaders in the digital governance space in the UK, including Public Digital and Nesta. Public Digital—a global consultancy that hires, develops, and supports digital teams and services—is made up primarily of former members of the founding team of the UK Digital Service, and now consults to governments around the world to support them on the route to digitization. At Nesta—an innovation agency for social change—the Beeck team met with Chief Practices Officer James Plunkett to discuss the role of external bodies in government innovation who are shaping change through multi-disciplinary teams. 

In December, the Beeck team welcomed a Japanese Digital Services delegation to the Beeck Center to discuss opportunities and challenges around innovation in service design and delivery. The representatives from Japan highlighted difficulties related to their country’s insulated government and a lack of familiarity with new technology. Overmann, Campbell, and Beeck Fellow Aaron Snow spoke about small recent successes in the U.S. around the federal government’s online COVID-19 test ordering initiative, and the launch of  new digital tools for state and local governments, but stressed that the U.S still has a long way to go in its digital service-delivery work. 

Catching Up: Where the U.S. is Lagging in Digital Service Design 

While this international engagement has led to a positive sharing of ideas, it also proves that the U.S. has significant work to do in order to be on par with other countries’ and organizations’ digital systems and adoption of digital services. 

In November, Snow and Beeck Center former analyst Ashlee Sellung joined Bogdan Ivanel—CEO of Commit Global—for a meeting at the White House to learn more about the organization’s “civil society infrastructure” and the open-source software emergency response systems they have built and deployed in several countries. One such initiative has allowed more than 1.4 million Ukrainian refugees to find reliable and timely information through the dopomoha.ro platform. Commit Global works directly with humanitarian organizations and government agencies to provide useful, up-to-date information in four different languages through the site.

In October, the Beeck Center hosted a delegation from Kazakhstan, organized by the Eurasia Foundation, to discuss the country’s whole-of-government digitization initiative. During these meetings, Beeck learned about their model, saw a demo of their digitization work, and discussed the difficulties of this kind of work in the American context. Kazakhstan’s success in the digitization of public services and documents is just one example of many countries taking strong steps toward improving public service delivery through technology.

“The awkward truth is, 10 years on, that the US is now lagging quite seriously,” Campbell said. “Kazakhstan showed that. We were like, ‘I don’t know how much we have to teach you.’”

 

Centering digital transformation in government 

Ukraine has also had significant success in their digital transformation, successfully creating a platform to facilitate digital service delivery and digital documentation and identification. Led by Snow, the Beeck Center has had ongoing conversations about the country’s recent digital advancements with Gulsanna Mamediieva, a tech and public policy research fellow at Georgetown University’s McCourt School of Public Policy, and director general for European and Euro-Atlantic Integration in Ukraine’s Ministry of Digital Transformation. Beeck is working toward formalizing a partnership with the ministry to explore the success of their government’s “Diia” app, which allows for convenient and secure interaction between the government and Ukrainian citizens. Ukraine was the first country with a digital ID valid everywhere in the country, and aims to make 100 percent of public services available online in the coming years. 

“Part of it’s about the code, but part of it’s about political prioritization,” Snow said. “It’s about how you manifest that in your government hierarchy and authorities. That’s the tricky bit.” 

This international engagement at the Beeck Center coincides with the global lens that both Snow and Campbell have applied to their work throughout their careers: Snow as the first CEO of the Canadian Digital Service and Campbell as the founder and former CEO of FutureGov, a UK-based consultancy that helped bring digital and design to governments around the world. It also builds upon efforts from the Beeck Center’s Digital Service Network, who hosted a discussion in March 2022 with the UK’s Public Digital team focused Universal Credit—an initiative to replace six social benefits and tax credits with a single, means-tested program to simplify the benefits system and take a “digital by default” approach. Last November, the Beeck Center hosted a panel and workshop at FWD50 and Snow returned to the conference this November to discuss the use of open source software in government systems. 

“I think a lot of the lessons that came out of these meetings was that America is great at funding, and inventing,” Campbell said. “But when it comes to adoption and mainstreaming of all of these tools and techniques, we’ve got a real problem in the US in terms of making mass adoption happen and the US really needs to sort of catch up.”

As the Beeck Center connected with international experts and officials throughout 2023, it’s evident that while the U.S. continues to spearhead innovation, there exists a clear need for increased adoption and integration of digital tools within the government. Moving forward, the Beeck Center remains committed to bridging these gaps and facilitating the exchange of ideas to drive meaningful digital transformation in service delivery.